Sheila Garvie - Mastermind or Victim

Product Information

Sheila Garvie died in a care home in 2014 at the age of 80 - spending the final years of her life suffering from Alzheimer's. Mr Nicol hopes that history after reading his book will judge Sheila Garvie more kindly. Max Garvie drank a lot and took drugs to excess, forcing her to indulge in outrageous sexual behaviour and assaulted her. He made Sheila join a nudist colony against her will and developed an obession with photography, pornography where he would snap nude picture of his wife, which he would display to his friends. The three including Tevendale's workmate Alan Peters were all charged with murder and had a ten-day trial at Aberdeen High Court in November 1968 with each putting forward a different version of events of what happened to Max Garvie. An exterior shot of the luxurious family home West Cairnbeg, near Laurencekirk, pictured only hours after Sheila was taken in by police, shows four-year-old son Lloyd’s bike and the two cars outside – a luxury in the late 60s. Glasgow-born Archibald Hall was a butler and a notorious serial killer. His first murder came in Dumfriesshire in southern Scotland in 1975 when Hall shot a former lover named David Wright in the head. Initially getting away with that, Hall moved to London, where he butlered for the Scott-Elliot family.

It was a crime which was the prelude to one of the most sensational court cases in Scottish legal history; the cold-blooded murder of millionaire farmer Maxwell Garvie and subsequent conviction of his wife, Sheila, and her lover, Brian Tevendale, in 1968. When it became clear that Tevendale was the killer, the prosecution case evolved into proving her guilt by her failure to somehow intervene in the assault on her husband, then doing nothing to bring Tevendale to justice before the three accused were arrested. He developed an obsession with pornography and nudism, indulged in casual sexual relationships with men and women and persuaded his wife to accompany him on holidays which she later described in a book as “hellish”. The abuse lasted for many years The widow put forward a defense claiming that the two men had appeared out of the blue that night, killer her husband and wrapped his body in tarpaulin and drove away stating she had no prior knowledge of their plans.I think she was trying to prove her innocence. I remember saying to her, ‘you don’t need to explain yourself to me. I am not here to judge you’ and she would just say ‘No. No, I want to tell you’. I just feel she wanted her side of the story out.”

a href="https://www.thefreelibrary.com/Why+we+murdered+a+millionaire%3b+For+the+first+time%2c+Brian+Tevendale...-a060432932On May 31, 1963, Burnett had forced his way into the couple's house and shot Thomas in the face at point blank range. Dead. He started an affair with Tevendale’s sister, Trudi Birse. But what Max didn’t plan for was that his wife and Brian would fall in love.

Peters claimed Sheila let them into the house and that she and Tevendale carried out the murder and he was simply observing. He died in 2007 from cancer. Allan Nicol's new book about the case (Image: Ringwood Publishing) Sheila married twice - she was divorced once and then widowed. She led a steady, respectable existence running a B&B in Stonehaven. A big change from her years as mistress of 'Kinky Cottage.' West Cairnbeg – near Fordoun, Kincardineshire – was once the home of millionaire Maxwell Garvie, who was brutally murdered by his wife Sheila and her lover Brian Tevendale, on May 14 1967.Prior to her marriage at the age of 20, Sheila Watson led a quiet life. She was brought up from a conventional Scottish home and her father was a stonemason on the Balmoral Estate and married the North-east's most eligible bachelor -Max Garvie who was 35. Now the games took a new turn with Max and Brian tossing a coin to see who would sleep with Sheila. When Max lost he insisted the three go to bed together. Then Max started an affair with Tevendale's sister, Trudi Birse. I do think deep down she felt there was no other way out. He was either going to murder her or she had to do something else. I think as well she was trying to protect her children and felt she was doing the right thing. Still only in their late 20s, they seemed to have everything- money, healthy children, a loving relationship - then it all went sour.

Related Articles Nothing..and no-one was sacred; For years, the mainland lived under the shadow of the bombers. Hundreds of innocent lives were scarred. She felt there was no way out, that she had met this boyfriend through her husband and she felt he was going to be her way out of the situation. She always referred to him as her boyfriend. It was as though Brian was still her boyfriend. “ APA style: I FORGIVE YOU; Wendy makes peace with mum who killed father.. (n.d.) >The Free Library. (2014). Retrieved Nov 28 2023 from https://www.thefreelibrary.com/I+FORGIVE+YOU%3b+Wendy+makes+peace+with+mum+who+killed+father.-a082205647He told the Mail: "She certainly managed to fool the police. Her father, let's not forget, was a war hero and an ex-policeman and she was married to a policeman. I think the police in those days might have been duped by the Tevendales. I feel her brother also benefited from that attitude too, because when he was first arrested, he managed to persuade police that Sheila killed Max and he only helped to move the body." nights out at hotels and nights in at West Cairnbeg - dubbed Kinky Cottage by locals because of Max's private nudist colony.