You are watching: Did kate really die in white collar
See more: Which State Produces The Most Roses For Valentine'S Day?
This is the huge Kate meta I’ve been threatening promising to write. Regardless of being all around the first two season the White Collar, there are spoilers for approximately season five. This was important to preemptively counteract some arguments. Fandom opinion the Kate often tends to fall into two camps. The very first is that she to be most definitely evil and also working versus Neal. The second is the her motives were a complete mystery, and we candlestick never know the truth around this enigmatic character. Sometimes the two mix come become, "We can never know, but she was most likely evil." i take a different stance. Ns posit the Kate was absolutely ~ above Neal’s side and was actively working to protect him. It would be easy to i disbanded this opinion as just one more headcanon, no much more valid than anyone else’s opinion. And yet I keep that my watch of Kate is, if not the “correct” one, the one many supported by canon. A bold claim. Can I ago it up? That’s just what i intend come do. I rewatched seasons one and two and took note of every scene the Kate either appeared in or was substantially discussed. There to be no suggest in going past season two, as Kate is essentially never mentioned after that, and never in any method that sheds light on her as a person. Negative views of Kate range from “pure evil” to “selfish, callous, and only the end for herself.” together a shorthand, I’ll it is in describing the negative views of Kate as the evil!Kate idea. Not everyone with e negative view the Kate would define her angry per se, yet I’ve collapsed them because that brevity and because, honestly, no one’s going to win any character positivity points with, “I nothing think she’s evil, I simply think she"s selfish, and also uncaring, and also going to sell Neal out.”We’re going to go illustration by episode, though ns going to it is in bringing in point out from throughout seasons one and also two. It’s not going to be, “We’re pointing out the pilot, so all I can talk about is the pilot.”So, let’s start with 1x01: PilotWe don"t find out anything around Kate"s personality or motivations in this episode; we just learn she exists. Well, and that she checked out Neal in prison for 3 and also a fifty percent years, prior to vanishing.It"s interesting. Every we watch of Kate is the prison defense video. A black and white, soundless video. We"re seeing her, technically, however we"re around as gotten rid of from her together we have the right to be.While, us don"t actually discover anything personal about Kate, this is the many the present will resolve her visits to that in prison. Supporters of the evil!Kate theory have straightforward explanation because that Kate"s stable visits: it was part of she con against Neal. Let"s study that. What to be Kate make the efforts to gain from Neal anyway, follow to this premise? There are three possibilities.1. Kate was after the music box and also had to be from the start. If this is true, climate why didn"t Kate go to Copenhagen through Neal? He was going after ~ the music box, and also rather than going through him, Kate combated with him. She refuse to go. That"s exceptionally counterproductive. She must be one idiot. One have the right to offer that Kate didn"t recognize Neal and also Alex were particularly going ~ the music box, but she didn"t even shot to find out, i m sorry is when again stupid. And if she didn"t recognize that the music box was Alex"s goal, climate I have the right to only boggle in ~ Kate"s stupidity. Among her associates to be after the very same goal she was, and also she never ever figured it out.So, girlfriend say, maybe Kate"s simply stupid. Except, for evil!Kate to make sense, she had to silly Neal for years, convincing him she loved him. This needs either Kate to it is in both incompetent and also brilliant, or Neal to it is in an idiot. And Neal"s no an idiot. And also before anyone suggests it, there"s no comparison in between Neal acquiring fooled by Rebecca/Rachel and also his connection with Kate. Neal and Kate weren"t just lovers; they functioned together, and it shows up they lived together. Neal to be observing Kate continually in a way he wasn"t observing Rebecca. Also, when again, Neal and Kate knew each various other for years. That type of long con is an extremely different from Rebecca"s comparatively short term game. Not only that, yet Rebecca was ex MI-5. She was a mystery agent, trained in deception. Kate to be not.There"s one much more problem through this scenario, i m sorry I"ll gain to in the next possibility.2. Kate wasn"t conning Neal native the beginning, but she was recruited by Adler and willingly working through him when the series started. Solves the problem of "Why didn"t Kate go with Neal come Copenhagen?" but there"s quiet a glaring flaw. Why the totality kidnapping and also hostage plot? Kate disappeared 4 months before Neal"s sentence was up. The made Neal wary and suspicious and got his safety up. It would have actually been a lot more efficient for Kate come wait the end those last few months, then as soon as Neal was out, get him come take she to his stash and the music box. (Since she assumed he had actually it.) Neal was propelled to provide Kate a much better life, and he would have actually been far more trusting of his girlfriend 보다 a shadowy conspiracy. If Kate was in on the con, climate why perform things the most challenging way? (As noted, this is additionally a difficulty with scenario number one.)3. Kate was never after the music box specifically, but she was only with Neal for what she can get indigenous him. Except, what was she acquiring from him the she couldn"t get elsewhere? particularly while Neal remained in prison. The wasn"t doing her any great then. Kate was an attractive woman, and she was a con artist. Does anyone think she couldn"t have found one more sugar daddy? Also, Kate thought she knew wherein Neal"s cache to be the whole time he remained in prison, however she only made a relocate on it as soon as Fowler entered the picture. No to point out that Kate left Neal and also survived there is no him. (Plus, if one is suggesting that Kate had selfish engine the entire time, climate that when again raises the question regarding why she didn"t walk to Copenhagen v him. Also if she was angry around being lying to, surely that would have actually made more sense to in ~ least gain in in ~ the big score.)As one can see, every the possibilities save on computer gaping holes. The alternate possibility, the Kate saw Neal faithfully because she cared about him, is straightforward and direct, and also requires no huge leaps the logic. 1x02: ThreadsWhile this is the episode in i beg your pardon we learn that throughout her last prison visit, Kate was signaling Neal via Morse code, much more important for this essay is the discussion Neal and also Mozzie have previously in the episode around Neal"s cache and the ar thereof. Neal reveals the he lied come both Mozzie and also Kate around where he hid his spoils. One of the staples that the evil!Kate idea is that Kate has Neal wrapped around her finger, and he"s too blinded by love to inquiry her. As we have the right to see, that"s no so. Neal is totally capable that being suspicious of Kate. (Though no more, i add, 보다 he"s suspiciously of Mozzie.) the doesn"t trust her unthinkingly.1x05: The PortraitFinally, an yes, really appearance through Kate. She and Neal have a genuine conversation. She requirements that Neal tell her whereby he hid everything, and also Neal refuses, saying "It"s the only leverage I"ve got." keep in mind that it"s not that the doesn"t trust her, yet that that disagrees v her on strategy. Much more evidence versus the idea that Kate has Neal wrapped about her little finger. He deserve to disagree with her, and also he does.Once again, we watch that evil!Kate is a complete incompetent, since if she"s trying to manipulate him with this conversation, climate she"s doing a terrible job. She"s an extremely forthright and blunt, for one thing, telling him directly up that she desires to recognize where he hid his spoils. Also, if Neal doesn"t desire to provide up the information, wouldn"t the make feeling to convince him to perform so? Neal doesn"t want to lose his leverage, but he"d an extremely likely change his song if Kate told him her life was at stake. She claims nothing the the sort. No, “He’s going to hurt me." No, "I"m scared." The just times she mentions peril is when she speak Neal it"s too dangerous because that him to recognize what she knows.She dram minimally to his emotions together well. Various other than saying she desires to come home, she doesn"t do emotional appeals. She doesn"t plead v him to trust her, she needs it. She doesn’t try anything like, “If friend love me, you’ll do this.” She doesn"t phone call him just how much she misses him. She doesn"t even directly tell him that she loves him. She speak Mozzie and asks the to pass it on. Kate"s a con artist. Faking feel is what she does. If she"s play Neal, why not play up the love and fear to acquire him to cave? Ironically, the truth that Kate shows much less emotion indicates that whatever she is emotion is much more likely to it is in real.1x08: tough SellThe huge Kate and Peter scene. World judge Kate for pulling a gun on Peter. Except, she"s right now being hosted hostage by one FBI agent. Also if one believes that Kate is willing working through Fowler and Adler, Peter is still the male who arrested her boyfriend and also has currently asked because that a mystery meeting. Of food she doesn"t to trust him. Girl"s comes prepared.I think this is Kate"s longest step in season one, and also yet it"s so hard to obtain a read on her. This is natural; she guard is going come be method up due to her connection with Peter and also the nature of this meeting v him. Not just that, but Peter is purposefully antagonizing she by not just wearing his FBI ring, however drawing fist to it. He’s not setup out to do her feeling comfortable. Whatever Kate’s true feelings are, it is in they "I dislike Neal and want him to die" or "Neal is the love of mine life and also I will certainly never give up ~ above him," she"s no going to display Peter her hand. She doesn"t like Peter, however she has no reason to. The last time they experienced each other, he to be arresting her boyfriend. She claims that the music box is her price to leave Neal alone, which could feed into the idea the she doesn’t love Neal and also really will certainly leave him for a price, yet we"ll learn later that Kate"s escape arrangement accounted because that both her and Neal. It makes simply as much sense to number that she’s informing Peter what he’ll believe in order to get what she wants. She stays silent once Peter asks her if she ever before loved Neal, but once again, everything her motives, she has zero factor to answer that question. (It"s such a "When walk you prevent beating her wife?" question. It automatically presumes the she doesn"t love Neal now.)She does warn Peter "don"t push him." ("He" is more than likely Fowler yet could it is in Adler.) Is the genuine issue for Peter? Is she only thinking of just how the splash back could affect Neal or her? that knows? There’s yes, really not enough to get a firm idea.Then we end the flash back, and Peter and Neal have actually a earlier and forth around Kate"s motives, but it doesn"t tell us anything new. Peter doesn"t to trust Kate, Neal does, rinse, repeat.1x09: bad Judgment This episode has a pertinent conversation between Neal and Mozzie:Mozzie: her keeper and also I actually agree top top something. What if she"s working with Fowler?Neal: I must talk come her. Climate I"ll know.In his conversations through Peter, Neal refuses to address the idea the Kate can be working against him. With Mozzie, however, that doesn’t have actually the exact same knee jerk defensiveness. Mozzie is Neal’s oldest friend and his trusted confidant. It makes sense that he would certainly be an ext honest. Once again, Neal is not unthinkingly in love through Kate. He provides the logical suggest that he need to talk to Kate before condemning her. No Mozzie nor Peter has offered Neal any type of real factor he need to trust your guts end his own opinions, particularly when he has no evidence of evildoing indigenous Kate herself. A lot of of human being who believe in evil!Kate cite the reality that Mozzie and also Peter don’t to trust her, so thus she was up to no good. Let’s examine that. Peter has actually spent a complete of something like 5 minutes roughly her. The first time he saw her, he to be arresting her boyfriend, and also the second time, well, I defined that scene in the “Hard Sell” part of this essay. Peter, by his own actions, yet justified, has never seen Kate at her best. And also his arguments for why Kate is no great are vague. His heat to Neal is, “I looked into her eyes and I did not see concern for you.” Really, that’s what he’s going with? the made eye contact during a time as soon as Kate’s anxiety level and guard were both means up, and he thinks he knows she soul? Peter problems that going ~ Kate will lead Neal earlier to a life of crime. And also like a an excellent friend, he doesn’t favor to watch Neal sad or hurt. This emotions are going to prejudice Peter against Kate. Together for Mozzie, one point one needs to remember is the until about halfway v season three, Mozzie is very possessive that Neal. That doesn’t like it once Neal lets new people in his life. He certainly shows this through Peter, but also with Neal’s season 3 girlfriend Sara. Prior to Neal and also Sara begin dating, Mozzie likes Sara. In “Burke’s Seven,” that approvingly notes the she is, “a lady that colors external the lines.” However, when Neal starts dating her, Mozzie becomes dismissive and also insulting towards Sara, comparing her to a Barbie doll and also the like. (And his Barbie doll comment is ceded in a very dismissive way.) as soon as Neal and also Sara rest up though, Mozzie remarks the he likes her. Mozzie doesn’t favor Neal’s girlfriends. (Once again, up with the center of season three.) that doesn’t favor sharing Neal. So, no, the fact that Peter and also Mozzie don’t to trust Kate is not proof of Kate’s ill intent. It’s proof that Peter and also Mozzie have their very own issues and also biases. 1x14: out of the BoxThis is the an initial time us get any information top top what Kate’s arrangement actually is. As Fowler described it, “Kate and I do a deal. Girlfriend both get brand-new identities. We get the box. Girlfriend disappear. Legally.” at this allude we have no details reason to referee this together true over not true, but we’ll get an ext information later, and also it’s worth noting the an initial time point out of Kate’s plan appears.This episode includes Elizabeth’s infamous line, “I think there"s a difference between loving the idea that someone and also actually loving who they really are.” This has actually been used plenty of time come dismiss the Kate/Neal relationship. Yet let’s look at this heat logically. Does Elizabeth recognize anything about Kate? go she understand anything around Kate and Neal’s relationship? Elizabeth has actually never met Kate, noþeles she knows, she got from Peter. This details is going to be incomplete, since Peter has actually no reason to exhaustively list everything Kate does, and also filtered v Peter’s anti-Kate bias. Elizabeth is wise, yet she’s no psychic. She doesn’t have any magical understanding into Kate or the Kate/Neal relationship.And then the aircraft blows up, and Kate dies. Ironically, after Kate’s death, we’ll learn far an ext about her motivation and plans 보다 we ever did as soon as she was alive. However I’m gaining ahead the myself. 2x02: need to KnowIn this episode, Neal and also Diana have actually a conversation about grief and loss. It’s below that Diana tells Neal, “I understand you blame yourself for what happened to Kate. Ns blame myself for Charlie. Yet Charlie wouldn"t have actually wanted me to execute that. He"d have actually wanted me to walk on through my life. I didn"t know Kate, however I"d guess: v she"d desire the very same thing.”If people are walk to take Elizabeth’s opinion indigenous “Out that the Box” as factual, then there’s no factor not to watch Diana’s opinion as simply as valid. ~ all, neither Diana nor Elizabeth has ever before met Kate, and also everything castle know, castle no 2nd hand. They’re same informed. Now, normally, I would certainly not in reality argue the Diana’s statement proves anything around Kate’s motivations. However if civilization are walk to usage the opinions of characters who have actually never met Kate and also don’t really know anything about her, climate let’s it is in intellectually honest and also acknowledge all of those opinions, consisting of the one the doesn’t repaint Kate in a negative light.2x06: In the RedThis is the episode wherein we listen Kate’s final phone call. Honestly, it’s also vague to offer an understanding into Kate’s motivation, however I’m including it for completeness sake. Kate: Hey, it"s me. Peter Burke is here. I don"t recognize why Burke"s here. Walk this readjust the plan?Honestly, the tells us nothing around what Kate to be planning, only that there was a plan. She dubbed Adler, however it doesn’t tell united state whether she called him together a partner, or a pawn who believed she was around to be free of him. So, the was unhelpful. 2x09: point BlankThis episode! In which our questions are answered! Well, few of them. In this episode, Kate’ plans and also motivations space actually revealed Fowler tells united state a an excellent deal the what we must know. Once he, Neal, and also Peter are pointing out Kate, Fowler looks at the very familiar snapshot of his hand on Kate’s shoulder and also remarks, “She to be signaling you with her ATM card the day, huh?” This is a small thing, however it’s precious noting, as it suggests that Kate was not Fowler’s willing partner. After all, if this to be a setup that Fowler and also Kate cooked up together, the would have known the was the plan, and he wouldn’t must ask Neal. Now, I intend one can argue the Kate and Adler were working together and also leaving Fowler in the dark, but that no make any type of sense. If Kate to be evil and also trying to draw Neal in by signaling him, there’s no factor for Alder to save that info from Fowler. It only undermines Adler’s do the efforts to get the music box, if his pawns have actually no clue what come expect. (Except once he’s killing them that course.) If you want to argue that Fowler is lying, I’ll obtain to that.Then, Fowler yes, really gets to the meat of things: what to be Kate planning. Here are the appropriate bits of conversation (I’ve reduced anything not pertained to Kate’s motives, but nothing relevant has actually been left out):Neal: Why"d friend buy the explosives?Fowler: Oh, the was Kate"s idea.